Cinderella was in an original, different version of The Wolf Among Us Season 1. Her character was modeled, textured, and even animated. However, she didn’t fit in with the final story for the game, so she was cut....and here's a still from that cut version. - Telltale Games says.
The developers clarified that you should not delve into these old developments and look for hints of a second season in them.

In case you were curious to know what Mr. Toad's glamour might've looked like in Season 1 - if he could've afforded it - here's some concept art for you. - Telltale Games says.
Many will say it's the Jersey Devil! But in one episode, Toad and Jersey were at the same time in Lucky Pawn. But apparently the developers abandoned the Toad with Glamours, and made the Devil from Jersey.

It looked like still images, but after a few seconds the camera started moving around. When people realized it was all rendered, people’s minds were blown. - Telltale Games says.
Demo video:
on Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/telltalegames/videos/809999583647800
on Twitter (X) - https://twitter.com/i/status/1580592542428848128