I saw some guides with an "accurate" gift guide but it just didn't work! I found this wiki and so far it has worked out for me!! I will link it here for reference of course, I give credit where it's due, but I will also list it all here for you all! Happy matchmaking! :D


https://kitty-powers-matchmaker-wik.fandom.com/wiki/Types


ARTY:

GREAT:
Haiku Poetry
Japanese Twig
Piece of Avant-garde Glass
Black and White Art Print

GOOD:
Black Rose
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Orchid
Platinum Necklace
Red Rose
Titanium Wristwatch
Wood Phone Case
Patchouli Haze Aftershave

BAD:
LED keyfob
Skull Ring
Stagz for Men
Waterproof GPS

TERRIBLE:
Action Figure
Bicycle Pump
Cowgirl Hat
Cute Animal Calendar
Executive Desk Toy
Green Mankini
Jar of Humbugs
Jump Rope
Mini Disco Ball
Nerd Humor Mug
Pedometer
Sarcastic Mug
Unicorn Toy


CHIC:

GREAT:
Executive Desk Toy
Titanium Watch (Male)
Platinum Necklace (Female)

GOOD:
Japanese Twig
Red Rose
Lavender Water
Black and White print

BAD:
Bicycle Pump
Haiku Poetry
Jump Rope
LED keyfob
Nerd Humor Mug
Pedometer

TERRIBLE:
Mimi for Women
Action Figure
Cowgirl Hat
Cute Animal Calendar
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Green Mankini
Jar of Humbugs
Mini Disco Ball
Sarcastic Mug
Skull Ring
Unicorn Toy
Wood Phone Case
Black rose
Patchouli Haze Aftershave

EDGY:

GREAT:
Skull Ring
Moshpit for Men
Miss Demeanour

GOOD:
Black and White Print
Sci-fi prop
Orchid
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Juggling Balls
Platinum Necklace
Green Mankini
Action Figure

BAD:
Red Rose
Jar of Humbugs
Nerd Humor Mug
Haiku Poetry
LED keyfob
Sarcastic Mug
Titanium Wristwatch
Unicorn Toy
Mini Disco Ball
Wood Phone Case
Mimi for Women

TERRIBLE:
Bicycle Pump
Cute Animal Calendar
Japanese Twig
Cowgirl Hat
Executive Desk Toy
Jump Rope
Pedometer
Black Rose

GEEKY:

GREAT:
Action Figure
Nerd Humor Mug
Skull Ring
Unicorn Toy

GOOD:
Cowgirl Hat
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Executive Desk Toy
Haiku Poetry
Japanese Twig
Jar of Humbugs
LED keyfob
Mini Disco Ball
Orchid
Sarcastic Mug
Titanium Wristwatch
USB Gramophone
Wood Phone Case

BAD:
Bicycle Pump
Black Rose
Cute Animal Calendar
Green Mankini
Pedometer
Platinum Necklace
Red Rose
Stagz for Men

TERRIBLE:
Jump Rope


GLAM:

GREAT:
Cute Animal Calendar
Green Mankini
Mini Disco Ball
Platinum Necklace
Titanium Wristwatch
Unicorn Toy
Pink cowgirl hat
Stagz for men
Mimi for women

GOOD:
Executive Desk Toy
Black and White Art Print

BAD:
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Japanese Twig
Jar of Humbugs
LED keyfob
Sarcastic Mug
Skull Ring
Wood Phone Case

TERRIBLE:
Action Figure
Bicycle Pump
Black Rose
Haiku Poetry
Jump Rope
Nerd Humor Mug
Pedometer
Orchid

HIPPY:

GREAT:
Crystal Ball
Cute Animal Calendar
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Haiku Poetry
Japanese Twig
Orchid

GOOD:
Black and White Print
Glass Art
Green Mankini
Jar of Humbugs
Unicorn Toy

BAD:
Action Figure
Black Rose
Cowgirl Hat
Jump Rope
LED keyfob
Mini Disco Ball
Miss Demeanor
Nerd Humor Mug
Red Rose
Sarcastic Mug
Skull Ring
Wood Phone Case

TERRIBLE:
Bicycle Pump
Executive Desk Toy
Pedometer
Platinum Necklace
Titanium Wristwatch


HIPSTER:

GREAT:
Executive Desk Toy
Haiku Poetry
Sarcastic Mug
Japanese Twig
Wood Phone Case

GOOD:
Action Figure
Bicycle Pump
Cute Animal Calendar
Crystal Ball
Green Mankini
Jar of Humbugs
Jump Rope
LED keyfob
Mini Disco Ball
Miss Demeanor
Nerd Humor Mug
Orchid
Pedometer
Platinum Necklace
Skull Ring
Titanium Wristwatch
Unicorn Toy

BAD:
Black Rose
Red Rose
Cowgirl Hat

TERRIBLE:
jar of humbugs
Stagz for Men


PRACTICAL:

GREAT:
Cute Animal Calendar
LED keyfob
Waterproof GPS

GOOD:
Bicycle Pump
Jar of Humbugs
Jump Rope
Pedometer
Red Rose
Sarcastic Mug
Stagz for Men
Wood Phone Case


BAD:
Action Figure
Black Rose
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Executive Desk Toy
Green Mankini
Nerd Humor Mug
Orchid
Platinum Necklace
Unicorn Toy

TERRIBLE:
Cowgirl Hat
Haiku Poetry
Japanese Twig
Mini Disco Ball
Skull Ring
Titanium Wristwatch


SPORTY:

GREAT:
Bicycle Pump
Jump Rope
Pedometer
Stagz for Men

GOOD:
Cowgirl Hat
Cute Animal Calendar
Green Mankini
LED keyfob
Orchid
Platinum Necklace
Red Rose
Sarcastic Mug
Unicorn Toy
Wood Phone Case
A Set of Juggling Balls

BAD:
Action Figure
Black Rose
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Executive Desk Toy
Mini Disco Ball
Nerd Humor Mug
Skull Ring
Patchouli Haze Aftershave

TERRIBLE:
Haiku Poetry
Japanese Twig
Jar of Humbugs
Titanium Wrist Watch

VINTAGE:

GREAT:
Jar of Humbugs
USB Gramophone
Lavender Water

GOOD:
Cute Animal Calendar
Haiku Poetry
LED keyfob
Sarcastic Mug
Titanium Wristwatch
Unicorn Toy

BAD:
Action Figure
Bicycle Pump
Black Rose
Ethnic Beaded Necklace
Executive Desk Toy
Jump Rope
Nerd Humor Mug
Pedometer
Platinum Necklace
Wood Phone Case

TERRIBLE:
Cowgirl Hat
Green Mankini
Japanese Twig
Mini Disco Ball
Skull Ring
Orchid
A single red rose