Pros (story):
+ plays like a movie
+ immersive world
+ character development
+ soundtrack gives you the feels
+ lots of customization options
+ many fun side quests
+ horse bonding
+ Dead Eye mode
+ "Yer a good boah"

Cons (story):
- very slow start
- horse does dumb things sometimes
- some quests are missable as you advance the story
- Abigail cheats in dominoes
- the existence of Micah Bell
- no cure for TB yet
- all endings are sad because of what happens in RDR1

------------------------------

Pros (online):
+ posse is fun with friends

Cons (online)
- bugs
- griefers
- The Grind
- can't sell wild horses
- Rockstar Launcher
- Rockstar Social Club

Enjoy your first playthrough as much as you can. Worth it for the story mode alone.

9/10

Pros (story): + plays like a movie + immersive world + character development + soundtrack gives you the feels + lots of customization options + many fun side quests + horse bonding + Dead Eye mode + "Yer a good boah" Cons (story): - very slow start - horse does dumb things sometimes - some quests are missable as you advance the story - Abigail cheats in dominoes - [spoiler] the existence of Micah Bell [/spoiler] - [spoiler] no cure for TB yet [/spoiler] - [spoiler] all endings are sad because of what happens in RDR1 [/spoiler] ------------------------------ Pros (online): + posse is fun with friends Cons (online) - bugs - griefers - The Grind - can't sell wild horses - Rockstar Launcher - Rockstar Social Club Enjoy your first playthrough as much as you can. Worth it for the story mode alone. 9/10